A Positive Approach To Employee Performance Improvement Through Discipline

Free Online Articles Directory

Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
AB Answers

Publish Article

0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Hello Guest
Login

Login via

Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out

Email

Password


Remember me?
Lost Password?

Home Page > Business > Management > A Positive Approach To Employee Performance Improvement Through Discipline

A Positive Approach To Employee Performance Improvement Through Discipline

Edit Article |

Posted: Mar 06, 2007 |Comments: 0
| Views: 820 |

Share

Smoothing the Consequences of Miscounduct with Accountability

For seventy-five years, American organizations have used a fairly standardized procedure to handle familiar personnel problems such as absenteeism, poor performance, and other misconduct. This approach, usually called “progressive discipline,” provides for an increasingly serious series of penalties – reprimands, warnings, suspensions without pay – when employees fall out of step with the organization’s expectations. When problems arise, the job of the manager is to find the punishment that fits the crime.

But today, a growing number of companies are moving away from using a criminal-justice mentality for employee performance improvement through corrective action. They are abandoning traditional approaches that focus exclusively on punishment. Instead, they are adopting an approach of accountability – employees with unfavorable performance, conduct or attendance issues are required to take personal responsibility for their choice of behavior.

Discipline and Recognition

One immediate difference is that traditional, punishment-based discipline systems ignore the great majority of people who never create disciplinary problems. In a non-punitive, “Discipline Without Punishment” approach, there’s a new step added to the process – a positive contact. Just as the policy is expected to resolve employee problems when they arise, it also makes clear that supervisors are expected to recognize employees when they perform well.

Recognizing good performance is no longer just good advice handed out in a management training class. Now it’s a formal policy requirement, a step of the organization’s overall discipline procedure.

Diffusing Problems

Supervisors continue to be responsible for beginning the correction process by employee coaching prior to formal disciplinary action. The exception is when the magnitude of the behavior warrants serious disciplinary action or even termination for a first offense.

In the early stages of disciplinary action, the Discipline Without Punishment approach replaces the familiar responses of verbal reprimands and written warnings with two comparable steps toward employee performance improvement: Reminder 1 and Reminder 2. Yes, they seem similar, but there’s more than mere semantic sleight-of-hand at work here.

Instead of being reprimanded for his mischief or warned about what will happen the next time he misbehaves, the employee is formally reminded of two important things. First, he’s reminded of the organization’s exact expectations of high-quality work, on-time performance, or whatever else has triggered the need for the discussion. And second, he is reminded that he has a responsibility for meeting the organization’s standards – he must do what he’s being paid to do and he must do it well.

The Last Chance

The biggest change from the traditional, punishment-based approach comes at the final step of disciplinary action. When the employee is one step away from termination, a dramatic gesture is needed to forcefully drive home the message that the end is at hand – one more time and you’re fired. But merely giving the employee a “final written warning,” or placing her on probation for some period of time, or creating a employee performance improvement plan aren’t powerful enough to clearly communicate the message “Once more and you’re out!” That’s why a disciplinary suspension from work is the best final step for a corrective action system.

Withholding Pay Does Not Work

traditionally, this disciplinary suspension has been without pay. The intent is that by depriving the employee of pay, he will come to his senses and return to work determined to do whatever is necessary to keep his job.

But the theory rarely works in practice. Employees who are placed on a three-day disciplinary suspension without pay don’t often return having seen the error of their ways and a commitment to excellent performance. They usually come back angry, all the organization has accomplished is creating a bitter employee.

There are other problems with using punishment as the basis for disciplinary action. Supervisors, many of whom are in the tricky position of being both on-the-job boss as well as off-the-job friend, often hesitate to place friends on an unpaid disciplinary suspension.

Because they know the family is also getting punished by the loss of pay, they may cut their people more slack and open themselves to charges of favoritism. And suspensions without pay just aren’t appropriate for exempt, knowledge-worker individuals.

A Paid Disciplinary Suspension

A “Decision Making Leave,” the final step of the responsibility-based Discipline Without Punishment process, provides all of the advantages of a disciplinary suspension as a final step and eliminates the drawbacks. This disciplinary suspension with a twist suspends the individual for one day and one day only.

On this day, the employee is required to make one of two choices: correct whatever problem brought him to this final step of the discipline process and make a commitment to fully acceptable performance in every area of his job in the future, or decide to quit and find greener employment pastures elsewhere.

Paying the employee for the day he’s away on “decision day” changes the supervisor’s role from adversary to coach. It demonstrates the organization’s good faith in wanting to see him change and return to fully acceptable performance, and is consistent with the values of almost every organization. By eliminating money as an issue, it doesn’t impact the family’s grocery budget and thus reduces the possibility of anger, hostility and even workplace violence.

Agreed Accountability

If the employee decides to remain with the organization and commits to fully acceptable performance in every area of the job (as almost all people placed on decision making leave do) and then doesn’t live up to his commitment, termination turns out to be much easier and guilt-free.

And should the employee challenge the termination in an EEOC complaint, unemployment hearing, or any other venue, the fact that the organization gave the person a day at its expense to decide whether he was willing to do then job he was being paid to do and the employee didn’t live up to his own commitment assures legal defensibility.

Traditional discipline approaches may indeed convince some problem employees to shape up, others to ship out. But punitive tactics can’t produce employees who are genuinely committed to the goals of the organization and the policies and rules by which they operate. We may be able to punish people into compliance, but we can not punish them into a commitment to employee performance improvement. And a culture of commitment is what today’s organizations really need.

Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/management-articles/a-positive-approach-to-employee-performance-improvement-through-discipline-113714.html”

(ArticlesBase SC #113714)

Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!

Dick Grote -
About the Author:

Dick Grote exclusively specializes in the field of employee performance improvement and management. Visit: http://www.groteconsulting.com/

Questions and Answers

Ask our experts your Management related questions here…200 Characters left

I m persuing project on Performance appraisals system of BSNL. I want type of performance appraisals followed by the BSNL Ltd. Please tell me the relevant sites for the same
What is the best way to monitor employee performance during their probationary period
When hiring employees do you emphasize positive

Rate this Article

1
2
3
4
5

vote(s)
0 vote(s)

Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish

Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/management-articles/a-positive-approach-to-employee-performance-improvement-through-discipline-113714.html

Article Tags:
employee performance improvement, employee performance appraisal, discipline without punishment

Related Videos

Related Articles

Latest Management Articles
More from Dick Grote

Employee Regulation

Documentation today may keep an employee’s discrimination claim away — or provide a sound defense if you listen to our labor law experts. (02:30)

Preparing for Annual Review

Believe it or not, it’s that time of year again–time for your annual employee review process. This year, instead of thinking of your annual review as a dreaded trip to the office, wouldn’t it be great to have a game plan ready to get you through it? (04:07)

E-Mail Laws

If you think the e-mail you just sent from the office is private, you wouldn’t believe who’s reading it. (01:35)

How To Play Basketball: Zone Discipline Drill

Follow the zone discipline drill to frustrate the offense and move into a zone. (04:47)

How to Find and Keep the Right Employees

How do you find the right employees, and how do you retain them? Andrew Field, founder and CEO of PrintingForLess.com, shares his employee strategy. (08:24)

Open Performance Review And Appraisal System (opras) In Tanzania

This paper will explains Tanzania experience of OPRAS, rationale of its introduction, its purpose, characteristics, its process, advantages, consequences and its expansion in Tanzania public sector

By:
viane sylvesterl

Business>
Human Resourcesl
Jan 30, 2010
lViews: 1,106

EMERGING ISSUES IN HRM

The management of Human Resources has now assumed strategic importance in the achievement of organizational growth and excellence. As globalization advances and we move into the information age, organizations need to adapt to the changes in technology and the changing issues in management of people.

By:
P. Pirakatheeswaril

Business>
Human Resourcesl
Jun 19, 2009
lViews: 8,877
lComments: 1

Reward Management And Motivation Theory

Before embarking on the discourse about reward management, it will be important to contextualize it within the field of management as a whole. Management can be defined as the act of organizing people together with the aim of attaining desired and predetermined goals and objectives laid down by an organization or individual.

By:
Carolyn Smithl

Business>
Managementl
Feb 24, 2010
lViews: 1,638

Effective school administration and management:

This paper enlightens school administrators and teachers on the purpose and importance of supervision in general and supervision of school records specifically. Types of supervision and inspection and what to inspect are indicated. The significance of school records and administration of the various records and those responsible for each record and the implications of failure to administer each of the records are discussed.

By:
Peter gbolagade Akintundel

Education>
Tutoringl
Sep 21, 2010
lViews: 220

5 Advantages of an Applicant Tracking System

An applicant tracking system can provide any business with the clear hiring edge against their competitors who are trying to scoop up candidates from the same talent pool. Here are five advantages that come with utilizing an applicant tracking system.

By:
Darwin Redshieldl

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

Do you need to close your company this year?

The New Year often brings a new start in business. For some this may mean a chance to close down a loss making enterprise and start afresh with a new debt free business. If you need help to make this happen, this article will point you in the right direction.

By:
Steve Thatcherl

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

Internet Based CRM Solutions May Be More Cost Effective

Internet based CRM solutions are becoming increasingly popular as small businesses are seeking to harness the power of customer relationship management software that only larger businesses have up until now had access to. Corporations hosted their own customized customer relationship software often specially made or customized to their sales and services. This was fine for them since they had the funds to invest but smaller and medium sized companies did not have this advantage until internet-ba

By:
CRM Logicl

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

How and Why to Become a CLEC

The following steps and implementation procedures are designed to give the ISP who wishes to plunge into the telecom business an idea of the processes and procedures necessary to become a CLEC (Competitive Local Exchange Carrier). These procedures also give you an opportunity to understand how much time and effort we put into your turn-key solution.

By:
Joseph Isaacsl

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

Promotional Bags Make Marketing Easier

Both promotional pens and promotional bags represent great ways to market your company and keep your customers loyal.

By:
BPMA Sourcingl

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

Protecting Your Reputation Online

Protecting your reputation online against attacks is important, if you don’t you will wake up one day with a rip off report posted on the internet. To remove rip off reports is very difficult. Allowing just anyone to say anything about your business on the Internet today is a big mistake. Do not forget that most of your potential customers now search the internet before they do business with you.

By:
Repairimagel

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

info GROUP Inc. – SWOT Analysis – Market Research Report On Aarkstore Enterprise

Aarkstore.com announce a new report “info GROUP Inc. – SWOT Analysis” through its vast collection of market research report.

By:
Aarkstore247l

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

HomeWithEquity — Renting vs Buying A Home

Is It Better to Buy or Rent?Whether renting is better than buying it depends on many factors, particularly how fast prices and rents rise and how long you stay in your home.

By:
sjpropertiesl

Business>
Managementl
Jan 05, 2011

Creating An Effective Employee Performance Management System

If your employee performance management system is not effective – in other words, your managers aren’t meeting their responsibility of getting their employee performance appraisals written, approved and delivered on time – here’s the first question to ask: What happens to the manager who doesn’t turn in all of his…

By:
Dick Grotel

Business>
Managementl
Apr 06, 2007
lViews: 764

A Positive Approach To Employee Performance Improvement Through Discipline

Smoothing the Consequences of Miscounduct with Accountability For seventy-five years, American organizations have used a fairly standardized procedure to handle familiar personnel problems such as absenteeism, poor performance, and other misconduct. This approach, usually called “progressive discipline,” provides for an increasingly serious series of penalties – reprimands, warnings, suspensions without pay…

By:
Dick Grotel

Business>
Managementl
Mar 06, 2007
lViews: 820

Employee Performance Appraisal – 5 Steps For The Ideal Assessment Form

Conventional wisdom says that there’s no such thing as a perfect employee performance appraisal form. And with so many sorry examples of appraisal forms around, conventional wisdom might almost seem correct. It’s not. There is an ideal model for the employee performance appraisal form. And getting the form right is essential…

By:
Dick Grotel
Businessl
Jan 25, 2007
lViews: 1,842
lComments: 1

Employee Performance Appraisal – An Ideal System

In America’s best-run and most-admired organizations, employee performance appraisal is a vital and vigorous management tool. No other management process has as much influence on individuals’ careers and work lives. Used well, employee performance appraisal is the most powerful instrument that organizations have to mobilize the energy of every employee in…

By:
Dick Grotel
Businessl
Jan 05, 2007
lViews: 4,339

Employee Performance Reviews — Dealing With Disagreements

What do you do when an employee disagrees with something you’ve written on their performance review? How can you prepare for this and deal with it effectively? Start by listening to figure out the source of the disagreement.

By:
Dick Grotel

Business>
Managementl
Mar 30, 2006
lViews: 1,974

Get Your Performance Appraisal Discussions Off To A Good Start (Part 1)

Too often, participants in performance appraisal meetings seem awkward and uncomfortable. To some extent, that’s unavoidable — it’s always a bit awkward for one person to deliver a formal assessment of the quality of work performed by another.

By:
Dick Grotel

Business>
Managementl
Mar 30, 2006
lViews: 1,146

Add new Comment

Your Name: *

Your Email:

Comment Body: *

 
‘);]]>
Verification code:*

* Required fields

Submit

Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy

Sign Up Today

Author Navigation

My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder

My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box

Dick Grote has 6 articles online

Contact Author

Subscribe to RSS

Print article

Send to friend

Re-Publish article

Articles Categories
All Categories

Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing

Business

Agriculture
Ask an Expert
Business Ideas
Business Opportunities
Corporate
Customer Service
Entrepreneurship
Ethics
Franchise
Fundraising
Home Business
Human Resources
Industrial
International Business
Leadership
Management
Negotiation
Networking
Non Profit Organizations
Online Business
Organizational
Outsourcing
Presentation
Project Management
Public Company
Public Relations
Sales
Six Sigma
Small Business
Strategic Planning
Team Building
Training

Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog

Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map

Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us

Business Info
Advertising

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.